THE HISTORY OF THE MR BALI HAI COCKTAIL

The Mr Bali Hai cocktail is an iconic tiki drink that traces its roots back to the golden era of Polynesian pop culture in mid-20th-century America. It was named after the famous Mr. Bali Hai restaurant, which opened in 1953 on Shelter Island in San Diego, California. The venue quickly became legendary—not just for its tropical ambiance, but for the cocktail that bore its name.

Originally created as a house drink to reflect the island-themed spirit of the venue, the Mr Bali Hai was designed to be strong, slightly sweet, and packed with exotic flavor. Unlike most tiki drinks, it includes coffee liqueur, giving it a rich, roasted character that stands out. The combination of both white and dark rum brings depth and complexity—blending bright sugarcane notes with deeper molasses tones.

The cocktail is a prime example of the playful experimentation that defined tiki culture: mixing Caribbean rums, tropical fruits, and unexpected ingredients like coffee. Modern versions of the Mr Bali Hai often highlight the coffee liqueur by using premium options like Mr Black Cold Brew Coffee Liqueur, which add bold flavor without excess sweetness.

Though it may not be as globally recognized as the Mai Tai, the Mr Bali Hai has carved out a loyal following thanks to its unique flavor profile and deep connection to tiki history.

THE COFFEE LIQUEUR FOR THE MR BALI HAI

Choosing the right coffee liqueur is essential for crafting a great Mr Bali Hai cocktail. Since this ingredient defines the drink’s signature richness, the quality you choose matters.

My top recommendation is Mr Black Cold Brew Coffee Liqueur. It delivers strong coffee intensity without being overly sweet, balancing perfectly with both the white rum and dark Jamaican rum. This lets the bright citrus and almond notes shine through while grounding the drink in a deep, roasted base.

If you prefer a softer approach, you can also experiment with Tia Maria or Kahlúa—but be prepared for a sweeter, rounder drink. For a true-to-style Mr Bali Hai, a bold cold brew coffee liqueur works best.

This cocktail encourages creativity. Feel free to play with rum blends or coffee liqueurs to find your personal favorite version of this tiki original.

More tiki cocktails?!

I am also on Instagram. Just drop in…

My Instagram channel. Here you can find all of my recipes. Constantly updated whether you are an experienced home bartender or a newcomer to the cocktail scene. I got a drink for everyone.